Detroit Red WingsFeatured

Red Wings Fall to Wild 4-2 in a Physical, Penalty-Filled Game 1 of Prospect Tournament

The Red Wings had eight power-play opportunities, striking only once in a 4-2 loss to the Minnesota Wild on Friday night.

It was the first game of the annual Prospect Tournament in Traverse City. Nerves were visible and mistakes were made, but the energy level shown by Detroit and Minnesota was noticeably strong. It was a physical battle all night long, with big bodies on both sides. Wild prospects Jordan Greenway, Louie Belpedio and Josh Thrower showed their size, as did Detroit’s Givani Smith and Cole Fraser.

The first period was dominated early by the Wild. Just past the midway mark, forward Dmitry Sokolov scored on the power play (one of four PP opportunities Minnesota would have). It was a clean wrist shot, beating goaltender Patrik Rybar (Czech) in close. Fortunately for Detroit, Filip Zadina was able to answer with a blast of his own on the man-advantage. With 1:15 to play, he ripped home a one-timer from the top of the right circle, tying the game. Shots were nearly even.

Filip Zadina following Game 1 of the Prospect Tournament. Friday, September 7, 2018. (Photo by Kevin Sporka)

Penalties were plentiful, as each period had four calls (including six slashing minors). Detroit, however, was unable to cash in on these prime chances, despite their potentially lethal top power-play unit consisting of Smith, Michael Rasmussen, and Joe Veleno, with Dennis Cholowski and Zadina on the point. Coach Ben Simon attributed the lack of success 5-on-4 to a small window of practice time.

“We had a ton of opportunities on the power play, but…we practiced one and a half days,” he said. “So we really haven’t had a lot of time to work on it. That’ll be a work in progress.”

Added Zadina, “We had lots of PP. We should score more, but it’s still the first game of the year; we’re just trying to be better every single opportunity you go on the PP.”

Zadina, despite scoring in the first, had a bit of a slow start to the tournament.

“Overall I thought he played very well,” said Simon. “The expectations for him are so high. We hold him to a high standard. It’s going to be tough for him to fulfill that every day. But obviously his goal was a nice shot. He wants the puck and he wants to compete. That’s one thing you notice right away. He cares, he competes…I thought he settled in as the game went on nicely.”

It seemed as though Minnesota was simply out-muscling Detroit at some points, with Greenway leading the way with his 6-6, 226 lb frame. Rybar, standing 6-3, was screened by Greenway as he took control of the area around the crease, screening the Czech goalie every chance he could take.

Simon thought Rybar was ‘phenomenal,’ especially for the first game.

“We gave up a lot of good scoring chances against…he made them look easy. He’s one of the positive bright sides of the game tonight for sure.”

“Greenway’s a big body,’ said Cholowski. “He’s hard to knock off the puck. That’s his biggest strength, he protects the puck well. They had some good players over there. Overall I thought we did a pretty good job though.”

Zadina was not intimidated by the physicality.

“I kind of got used to it from last year in Halifax, we play a little bit more physical hockey too. It didn’t surprise me lots. I was kind of expecting it, [that] it would be like a huge game, and it was a huge game. It was the first game; I felt kind of tired period and first half, but then I was getting better.”

The second period was noticeably weak for Detroit, as they had all four power plays, failing on each. Cholowski had a great scoring chance in the slot but waited far too long and the defender was able to get block it with his stick. There were a few other opportunities where Wings players hesitated too long. David Pope nearly scored, ripping a slap shot off the post.

Dennis Cholowski after Game 1 of the Prospect Tournament. Friday, September 7, 2018. (Photo by Kevin Sporka)

Wild forward Ivan Lodnia gave his team the lead with assists from Greenway and Gerry Fitzgerald (all three of these players had outstanding games, and they combined for six points).

Early in the second, Smith was provoked by Thrower, who dropped the gloves. Smith did not oblige, choosing not to engage in a fight, something he is known to do from time-to-time.

Coach Simon said the team as a whole showed good discipline.

“We want to see these guys play. We know who’s tough on our team. We don’t want guys to get hurt. We want guys to stick together and stand up for each other, but I thought overall our discipline was pretty good. We didn’t take a ton of penalties; unfortunately had some breakdowns on our penalty kill.”

In the third, Fitzgerald extended the lead to 3-1, set up nicely by Greenway. Rybar stood no chance of stopping it as the puck shot across the crease and was rocketed home on the one-timer

One minute later, Jared McIsaac (2018 2nd round pick) scored with a nice long shot, while Rasmussen screened goalie Kaapo Kahkonen.

Damien Giroux then potted the empty net tally with seven seconds to play in the game.

Givani Smith played very well. In addition to showing good discipline throughout the contest, he also had some very nice plays. His play was indicative of his experience at these prospect events.

“I think Smitty did a good job of not complicating things, you know, playing to his strength,” said Simon. “He’s forechecking, playing the body. That’s when he’s most effective. When he’s doing that, that’s when he’s playing to his strengths. He had a pretty solid game tonight.”

Why Detroit lost

Zadina: “They play a little more physically than we did. They had a couple nice goals, but they were on the puck in our zone way more than we were in the offensive zone. We’ve got to play more with the puck.”

Cholowski: “Special teams was a big part of today’s game. Our power play wasn’t the best. We would have liked to have been better there. Penalty kill wasn’t too bad, but it’s kind of hard to get any flow into the game when it’s just special teams the whole team.”

Simon thought the players were a bit nervous and anxious, and “running on adrenaline.”

“I think we got better structurally as the game went on.”


Detroit hopes to bounce back tonight against the Dallas Stars, of which former Grand Rapids Griffins head coach Todd Nelson is now an assistant coach. Dallas, down 5-3 in the third period, rebounded with four unanswered goals to beat the Rangers last night. The Wings have their work cut out for them in this matchup.

Tournament Scores

Carolina def. St. Louis 4-1

Columbus def. Chicago 4-3

Dallas def. New York 7-5


Other Notes

Cole Fraser gave up his position trying to make a big hit at the blue line a couple times. He sometimes sacrifices his defensive play for his physical play, sometimes to his detriment. He is also a bit clumsy at times.

I thought defenseman Jared McIsaac played really well. He’s a smart player, didn’t make any noticeable errors, and knows where his teammates are on the ice. Very good puck skills and hockey sense.

Defenseman Vili Saarijarvi was absent during the third period, leading to the Wings working with five D the rest of the game.

Zadina took a stick to the face at the end of the first period but appeared to be fine the rest of the game.

I wanted to see more from Joe Veleno. He didn’t show much in this first game, but he has strong playmaking abilities. Hopefully, some of those skills will be showcased this weekend.



Fox Sports Go, as well as various team websites, are streaming every game of this tournament.

Follow me on Twitter @KevinSporkaHOHM for continued coverage of the Prospect TTournamentall weekend long.


Kevin Sporka

Kevin Sporka

Kevin Sporka is the Senior Media Analyst and Detroit Red Wings beat writer at HOHM. He is also the author of the Fantasy Hockey Fridays, In Retrospect, Milestone Monday, and Legends By the Number segments.
Kevin Sporka

Latest posts by Kevin Sporka (see all)

Back to top button