FeaturedNational Hockey League (NHL)Top List Countdowns

Top 10 American Hockey Players of All-Time

Eventually other greats will crack the top ten such as current superstar Patrick Kane when his career comes to a close. Debates can be made for many other generational greats but these ten gentlemen certainly come to mind when you think of the best American hockey players to ever lace them up.
How would you rank your top 10?
Who would be your #1?

  1. Mike Modano
     June 7, 1970 (Age 45.027) in Livonia, Michigan  
    Minnesota, 1st round (1st overall), 1988 NHL Entry
    Hall of Fame: 
    Inducted as Player in 2014
    1499 GP, 561 Goals, 813 Assists, 1374 Points
    176 GP, 58 Goals, 88 Assists, 146 Points.
    Modano is the top U.S.-born scorer ever, regular season and playoffs. He was also a true icon for the Minnesota/Dallas Stars franchise and would go on to win a Stanley Cup in 1999.
  2. Brett Hull
    August 9, 1964 (Age 50.329) in Belleville, Ontario  
    Calgary, 6th round (117th overall), 1984 NHL Entry
    Hall of Fame: 
    Inducted as Player in 2009
    1269 GP, 741 Goals, 650 Assists, 1391 Points
    202 GP, 103 Goals, 87 Assists, 190 Points
    I know, I know you’re probably thinking he wasn’t actually born in the U.S.A., but Brett competed for the country internationally and adopted it as his homeland. He won the Hart Trophy as NHL MVP in 1991, which was also the same year in which he recorded 86 goals, the most ever for a player not named Wayne Gretzky. Hull was also a huge factor of the team that knocked off Canada to win the 1996 World Cup. He won two Stanley Cups including one with Mike Modano in 1999.
  3. Chris Chelios
    Born: January 25, 1962 (Age 53.160) in Chicago, Illinois  
    Draft: Montreal, 2nd round (40th overall), 1981 NHL Entry
    Hall of Fame: Inducted as Player in 2013 (Full List)
    Career: 1651 GP, 185 Goals, 763 Assists, 948 Points
    Playoffs: 266 GP, 31 Goals, 113 Assists, 144 Points
    Won three Norris Trophies and three Stanley Cups.
  4. Brian Leetch
    Born: March 3, 1968 (Age 47.123) in Corpus Christi, Texas  
    Draft: NY Rangers, 1st round (9th overall), 1986 NHL Entry
    Hall of Fame: Inducted as Player in 2009
    Career: 1205 GP, 247 Goals, 781 Assists, 1028 Points
    Playoffs: 95 GP, 28 Goals, 69 Assists, 97 Points
    Leetch was the total package as a defenseman. He won a Stanley Cup and two Norris Trophies.
  5. Joe Mullen
    Born: February 26, 1957 (Age 58.128) in New York, New York 

    Hall of Fame: Inducted as Player in 2000
    Career: 1062 GP, 502 Goals, 561 Assists, 1063 Points
    Playoffs: 143 GP, 60 Goals, 46 Assists, 106 Points
    The three-time Stanley Cup champion was the first American to score 500 goals in the NHL.
  6. Frank Brimsek
    Born: September 26, 1915 in Eveleth, Minnesota  
    Hall of Fame: Inducted as Player in 1966
    Career: 514 GP, 252 Wins, 2.70 GAA, 40 SO
    Playoffs: 68 GP, 32 Wins, 2.54 GAA, 2 SO
    Brimsek achieved a very rare triple in the 1938-39 Season: a Calder, Vezina and Stanley Cup. He added a second Cup and Vezina with Boston in 1941.
  7. Pat LaFontaine
    Born: February 22, 1965 (Age 50.132) in St. Louis, Missouri  
    Draft: NY Islanders, 1st round (3rd overall), 1983 NHL Entry
    Hall of Fame: Inducted as Player in 2003
    Career: 865 GP, 468 Goals, 545 Assists, 1013 Points
    Playoffs: 69 GP, 26 Goals, 36 Assists, 62 Points
    LaFontaine is the best American ever in terms of points per game (1.17).
  8. Tom Barrasso
    Born: March 31, 1965 (Age 50.095) in Boston, Massachusetts  
    Draft: Buffalo, 1st round (5th overall), 1983 NHL Entry
    Career: 777 GP, 369 Wins, 3.24 GAA, .892%, 38 SO
    Playoffs: 119 GP, 61 Wins, 3.01 GAA, .902%, 6 SO
    Much of Barrasso’s success came very early in his career, earning Vezina and Calder honors in Buffalo. That was followed by back-to-back Stanley Cups in 1991 and ‘92, when he was as a critical member of the Pittsburgh Penguins. His 369 wins are second only among American goalies to John Vanbiesbrouck’s 374, but Barrasso got his in 105 fewer games.
  9. Phil Housley
    Born: March 9, 1964 (Age 51.117) in St. Paul, Minnesota  
    Draft: Buffalo, 1st round (6th overall), 1982 NHL Entry
    Hall of Fame: Inducted as Player in 2015
    Career: 1495 GP, 338 Goals, 894 Assists, 1232 Points
    Playoffs: 85 GP, 13 Goals, 43 Assists, 56 Points
    Housley is the top-scoring American defenseman of all-time, and fourth among all NHL blueliners.
  10. Jeremy Roenick
    Born: January 17, 1970 (Age 45.168) in Boston, Massachusetts  
    Draft: Chicago, 1st round (8th overall), 1988 NHL Entry
    Career: 1363 GP, 513 Goals, 703 Assists, 1216 Points
    Playoffs: 154 GP, 53 Goals, 69 Assists, 122 Points
    Know as J.R., Roenick recorded three 100-point seasons.
Igor Burdetskiy

Igor Burdetskiy

Founder, Editor-in-Chief, & CEO at Hooked on Hockey Magazine
I grew up playing Ball and Roller Hockey day and night somewhat religiously throughout elementary and middle school. The two don't compare though when I lace up the skates and hit the ice. I live and breathe hockey beyond the perspective of "it's just a game" and I will gladly talk hockey for hours with anyone. Hockey is more than just a lifestyle, it's a culture of passionate people who make memories every time the puck is dropped. Hockey has not only helped me get through some of the hardest times in life but has created some of the best memories to date. Want to talk hockey with me? Shoot me an email: iburdetskiy@hookedonhockey.com and let's talk some hockey!
Igor Burdetskiy
Back to top button